The Quarterback Must Go Down
By Bill Chuang
Head Columnist
10/17/07
Archive

I was amused to read that Wade Phillips, head coach of the Cowboys, that his game plan was to stop the Patriots from running, thus forcing them to pass.  Well his game plan was successful.  The Cowboys held the Patriots to 2.6 yards /rush, but allowed Brady to carve them up for 388 yards and 5 touchdowns.  You can’t really blame him for this game plan.  Phillips is from the old school of football that believes in the axioms “establish the run,” and “stop the run.”  There’s an interesting article on coldhardfootballfacts.com in which the writers basically debunk the myth that it takes a great running game to win championships.  It doesn’t really take any elaborate statistics to know that only one running back has ever won the rushing title and the Super Bowl in the same season.  That was Emmitt Smith in 1993.  On the other hand, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Joe Montana have all won Super Bowls without great rushing attacks.  Kurt Warner had Marshall Faulk, but he was also a great receiver as well as a great runner.

The league has changed to favor more passing, and yet most coaches still believe that the path to Super Bowl glory requires his team to “establish the run.”  Perhaps Bill Walsh truly was a genius when he ditched this idea and decided to establish the pass with his West Coast offenses.  The Steelers are probably the guiltiest of this offense, having had success with Cowher Power over the past decade and a half.  Ben Roethlisberger is often criticized by the pundits who claim that he is only successful if he has a good ground game and when he throws fewer than 20 passes per game.  I’ve watched every Steeler snap for the past decade, so I can say for sure that the Steelers’ vaunted ground game would go nowhere without Roethlisberger’s timely and sometimes incredible third down passes.

This brings me back to the idiocy of Wade Phillips’ game plan.  Bill Belichick is famous for taking away his opponent’s greatest weapon.  Though this may seem pretty obvious, it was not that clear for Philips.  The Patriots’ greatest weapon is Brady, not Sammy Morris.  I wonder how Belichick, supposedly the NFL’s greatest defensive mind, would attack a Tom Brady led offense.

Put probably way too simplistically, there are two schools of thought on pass defense.  You can drop back the defenders and cover the receivers which is basically the idea of the cover 2, or you can blitz to pressure the quarterback and leave the defensive backfield vulnerable.  Of course you can do both, but not at the same time.  The trick is not to let the offense know which strategy you’re using.  Brady routinely beats them both.  When he is on his game, he is unstoppable.  He can be thrown off his game, though, if the rush pressure gets to him.  Somehow, Jason Taylor and the Dolphins defense routinely find ways to get to Brady.  He has lost in Miami 2 of the past 3 years, and barely escaped in 2005 when they did win.

I’m surprised more coaches don’t see this and apply maximum pressure to get to Brady,  especially for a team like the 0-6 Dolphins who the Patriots play this Sunday.   Their attitude should be, “He’s going to beat us anyway, so we might as well take him down.” All teams should have this attitude because the way Brady’s playing this year, no one will stop him.

I’m not advocating that some defensive lineman should take out his knees, but he barely gets dirty during a game.  He was sacked 3 times Sunday, which doubled his sacks for this season.  Why wouldn’t a defensive coordinator just rush all 11 defenders to get to him?  Brady would in all likelihood complete a pass to someone (they would all be open), which would go for a long touchdown, but they’d probably score anyway, so you might as well get some hard hits on Brady.

Al Davis famously said, “The quarterback must go down.  And he must go down hard.”  Quarterbacks are only human, even Brady.  If they go down hard enough, often enough, they will remember and play with more caution.  The point is to get them out of their comfort zone, not necessarily to hurt them.  Brady has played in his comfort zone all season.  It’s time someone took him out of it.