Home
NFL Draft
Fantasy Football
NFL Analysis
College Football
Mock Draft Database
Columns
Contacts
Links

Tuck's Rule Returns to Beat the Patriots

by Bill Chuang
Head Columnist
2/4/08
Archive



It’s the Circle of Life, though New Yorkers may put it more bluntly with “What goes around, comes around”.  In the 2002 Divisional Playoff game which pitted the Raiders vs. the Patriots, New England  This launched the Patriot Dynasty.  Skip to the 2008 Super Bowl.  Justin Tuck and his cohorts on the New York Giants defensive line effectively put an end to that dynasty and even call into question the existence of the so called dynasty.  To be fair, Tuck had just 2 of the 5 sacks of Brady tonight.  Strahan, Mitchell, and Alford had the others, but this line applied constant pressure on Brady all night and hit him hard even when he got the ball off.  I’m not sure how this team was able to do what 18 other teams could not do this year, that is get to Brady and knock him off his game.  The pressure seemed to come immediately and from all angles.  I actually felt rather sorry for Brady tonight.  He reminded me of the Burmese Soldiers who were being cut in half by a .50 caliber machine gun in the latest Rambo movie.  The defensive MVP really was Osi Umenyiora who turned Patriots pro bowl left tackle Matt Light into a turnstile.  Though he did not get any sacks, Umenyiora was constantly in Brady’s face, and hitting him hard just after releasing the ball.  One of the big differences I noticed in this game as opposed to a regular season game is that the referees let the players play.  There were no ticky tack roughing the passer calls that we’re so used to seeing Brady get.   I was actually impressed by Brady’s toughness tonight.  He usually never gets hit, so we never get to see how tough he is, but he kept on getting up after taking a beating. received a gift when Tom Brady had an apparent fumble reversed due to an obscure, still difficult to understand rule called the tuck rule.

It’s hard to believe Eli got the MVP.  He has a way of making some terrible throws, then having some very good plays to make up for those.  His quarterback rating was in the 70’s, but he made the plays when he needed to.  In my opinion, David Tyree should be going to Disney World.  He made the most spectacular catch ever in a Super Bowl, eclipsing even Lynn Swann’s acrobatic catch in Super Bowl 10.  He also scored the first Giants touchdown on a nice grab in traffic.

Now that their team has lost the Super Bowl, the pain for Patriots fans has just begun.  All that talk about this team being the greatest in the history of all sports has just gone out the window.  They can’t even claim to be the best team in the NFL this year.  Sure they were undefeated in the regular season, but they lost in the biggest game of the year when they were double digit favorites.  Can this team even claim to be a dynasty?  The past dynasties: the 70’s Steelers, 80’s 49ers, and 90’s Cowboys never lost a Super Bowl.   Though this team won 3 Super Bowls and had an undefeated regular season, they just lost the biggest game in their history.  True, the Cowboys of the 90’s also won only three Super Bowls, but ironically, since they never got to a fourth, they never lost one.  This loss tonight will loom large in the bar rooms of America as we debate whether or not the Patriots truly are a dynasty.

Next up for the Patriots is a date with the Commissioner and the Senate Judiciary committee.  In case you haven’t heard, the whole Spygate scandal is back in the news.  Senator Arlen Specter, a big Eagles fan wants to know why the Spygate tapes were destroyed by commissioner Goodell.  Previously, the commissioner had stated that he had all the tapes from the Patriots and that he was satisfied that they did not cheat in any Super Bowl.  He then destroyed all the tapes.  Every football fan outside of New England let out a collective “what the f—k” when he did that.  Well it turns out that Goodell only had tapes back to 2006.  Since the Patriots last Super Bowl win was 2005, of course he didn’t have any evidence of Patriots cheating in the Super Bowl.  The destruction of the tapes even prompted New Jersey lawyer to file a class action lawsuit on behalf of all Jets fans who felt they were cheated.  Because this particular lawyer had a history of filing frivolous lawsuits, no one particularly took him seriously and expect this lawsuit to get thrown out.  Enter Arlen Specter, ranking republican on the Senate Judiciary committee who wants to get to the bottom of this.  He likens the destruction of these tapes to the CIA destroying evidence.  This will certainly ad credibility to the lawsuit.  As if on cue, a new player emerged in the past few days.  This man, Matt Walsh, worked for the Patriots video department and has intimate knowledge of the workings within that department.  He has implied that he knows something which could be very harmful to the Patriots.  Both Specter and Goodell want to talk to him.  Then yesterday, it has come out that the Patriots taped the Rams final walkthrough prior to Super Bowl XXXVI.  This would be the proverbial “smoking gun” that we’ve all been looking for.  The Patriots of course denying any knowledge of this tape while they frantically feed their shredders.  As I stated in an article earlier about this incident, Belichick will not survive it.

The Patriots will have to deal with the impending free agency of Asante Samuel.  He is one of the top 5 cornerbacks in the league, and will command top dollar when he hits the market.  They almost certainly will lose him.  Randy Moss is the other big question mark.  He was undoubtedly the best receiver in the regular season, but had only 7 catches in the post season.  His value to the team goes far beyond catches though.  Because of Moss, Welker rarely sees a double team and Maroney never sees “8 in the box”.  Can the Patriots afford such an expensive decoy?  If the Patriots do not continue their dominating ways, will he remain the “happy” Randy Moss we’ve seen this season, or will he revert to his old ways, ie., playing only when he wants to, leaving the field before a game is over, playing at half speed when he is not the primary receiver.  Some team with lots of cap space will offer Moss a huge multi year contract.  The Patriots would not be able to match it, especially since they paid big free agent money for Donte Stallworth and may have to renegotiate Wes Welker’s contract.  For his part, Moss has stated he loves playing with Brady, but since he’s on the downside of his career, and his free agency value will never be higher, can he forgo one last huge offer from another team?

As long as the Patriots have Brady, they will be in contention, but the Giants showed the league tonight, that Brady is merely mortal.  The usually unflappable “Tom Terrific” can be flapped by bringing lots pressure.  No team will make Jacksonville’s mistake and let Brady sit back to pick the secondary apart.  Brady will see constant pressure next year, and without Moss to heave it up to, the pressure will be much more effective.

The Patriots did not make any friends in their quest for perfection this year.  First there were the complaints about running up the score, and then in the playoffs, several Chargers complained of dirty play by the Patriots.  Osi Umenyiora then came out before the Super Bowl and complained of a dirty play by Matt Light who he later embarrassed in the Big Game.  The Patriots may be as disliked by other players around the league as they are by other fans around the country.  They will have to play next season with even bigger targets on their backs, but this time, their veneer of invincibility will be gone.  In addition, their defense will be a year older.  The linebackers who are the heart of this defense, are by far the oldest in the league.  Seau will be 40 (probably will retire)!  Linebacker is the most physically demanding position of the field.  Intelligence and guile will only get them so far.  They need to make plays and their bodies will eventually give in.  Vrabel had the best season of his career, and is unlikely to repeat it.  Help will come in the draft where they have San Francisco’s seventh pick, but it’s unlikely they will be able to draft an impact defensive player, even with that pick.

Keep your heads up Boston Fans.  Spring training is right around the corner, and there should be a lot of 19-0 T- shirts available on Ebay.