TheFootballExpert.com
logo
The Football Expert
Michael Abromowitz's Column
Greg Cox's Column
Mock Draft Database
2006 NFL Draft
Contacts
Discuss the NFL Draft at FootballsFuture.com and post your own mock draft
Is He Really an Underclassman?
by Michael Abromowitz, Michael@thefootballexpert.com, 1/3/06
Previous Columns
2/20/2005
2/28/2005
3/18/2005
5/27/2005
8/10/2005
8/30/2005
9/14/2005
9/20/2005
9/30/2005
10/05/2005
10/12/2005
10/24/2005
11/10/2005
12/16/2005
Quickly after the Fiesta Bowl, Ohio State WR Santonio Holmes declared he was leaving college early to enter the NFL draft.  Very few were actually shocked by this decision, mostly because Holmes figures to be a first round draft pick and possibly the first receiver off the board.  But my question is why does Holmes even have to declare at all?   Holmes athletically is a redshirt junior, but academically he is a senior, and is on pace to graduate this year.  When the media mentions a player is leaving school early to enter the NFL draft it bothers me.  Saying a player is leaving early seems to mean a player is leaving college without a diploma, and many times this is not the case.  Holmes is considered to be leaving Ohio State “early” because he still has one year left of eligibility, even though he is expected to graduate.

What really bothers me about this more than anything is the reputation of the school being hurt.  Fans quickly assume that Holmes’ early departure signifies what many have all concluded many years ago:  Ohio State is a football factory, where wins are celebrated more than diplomas.  But this is not the case.  Santonio Holmes will graduate from The Ohio State University.  Yes, Ohio State does care about academics. 

Last year, Heath Miller, now a tight end for the Pittsburgh Steelers, left school “early.”  Miller came from the University of Virginia, which has been known as one of the elite academic institutions in division I football.  Just as in Holmes’ case, the media mentioned Miller as an underclassman.  Miller, also was a redshirt junior, and did receive his diploma last May.  Miller received numerous academic awards.  But on draft day, Miller was labeled a “junior.”  Fans must have been appalled by this.  The University of Virginia, which has long held a academic reputation ever since it was created by Thomas Jefferson, had sunk to the lows of other division I teams:  a football factory.  But if the fans only knew:  Miller did not leave early, he just happened to graduate in four years, the same time span UVA expects all of its students to.  Just a note:  UVA gives all if its students 8 semesters to graduate.  This is why so many seniors on the team are in graduate school. 

I hope that the NFL looks upon this problem, and revises it.  Many may not believe this is a big problem, but I believe it is a huge problem.  This could affect college recruiting and the players’ reputations.  When a college coach comes to a recruit’s house, he will try to persuade to the parents how important academics are and that he will do everything in his power for the recruit to leave his university with a degree.  Well a parent might think Jim Tressel and Al Groh are a bunch of liars because of Miller and Holmes’ early departures. 

In the player’s case, people may seem to believe if a player leaves “early” that he is either stupid because he cannot finish school or is just very greedy and only cares about the money.  The media fails to tell the fans that he is graduating and is getting a job (which all college students do after graduation).

The media and NFL need to change what an “underclassman” is.  A student who is on pace to graduate, but still has eligibility to play should not be labeled an “underclassman” or “early entrant.”   It is not fair to the player or his school.  Instead he should be given the label he deserves: “senior,” because academically he is a senior.   You go to college to get a degree, and this is just what many players such as Holmes and Miller do (they also play football).  They just happen to get the degree in four years instead of five.