Quantcast


Fixing the Pro Bowl
By Jared Donnelly, 2/23/07

Saturday Night came by and once again I found myself in front of the television watching the way a dog does when its owner is eating a steak. I was excited, my palms were sweaty, I had some adult beverages in the refrigerator, and I knew that I was going to be entertained. And I thought to myself, “why can’t the Pro Bowl be like this?”

NBA All-Star weekend has it down to a science. It is an entire weekend of the greatest athletes in the world showing off their talent. Slam Dunk contests, Rookies vs. Sophomores, three point shooting contests, skills competition, Barkley vs. Bavetta, and the Title Nine sponsored shooting stars competition make for an enjoyable night that you can tell the players really enjoy. The game is on Sunday and for the most part, I really believe that the players like that as well. All of these things are what separate the NBA All-Star experience from the lowly NFL Pro Bowl.

The Pro Bowl is the worst of all All-Star games. That is of course, if you don’t count hockey and well, I don’t count hockey. The game is boring, there is no real excitement surrounding it, and there are just too many people to care about. Nobody sits at home and says to their friends “I am really torn on who to vote for safety in the Pro-Bowl.” And I can think of about a million and one things I would rather do than try and figure out what makes one offensive lineman start over another.

Unlike politicians, I quickly thought up a plan to fix the Pro Bowl. Ladies and gentlemen, without further ado, the new and improved, NFL Pro Bowl Extravaganza.

The NFL needs to take a note from the NBA and do an entire weekend of events. You know all of those skills competition type events the NFL has? Well, let’s have all of those on Saturday night, a three hour event like the NBA. The weightlifting competition, QB competition, NFL’s fastest man, kicker P-I-G, and one more: Who wouldn’t love to see the NFL’s top three WR’s take their QB’s with them in a one on one pass catching competition against the top three CBs? Think about it, Carson Palmer throwing to Chad Johnson who is covered by Champ Bailey. Points are awarded for catches, yards, and touchdowns. Put these options in video games, market them by giving away a car, televise it, hype it up, whatever the NFL has to do to give this thing legs because once it does, it will do its own running.  I see this as a cash cow for the NFL.

As for the actual game itself, let’s liven this up a bit. The reason that it is so boring is because nobody, I repeat, nobody except Sean Taylor cares about this thing. (Did you see that hit? Can we just start calling him Sean-vict Taylor and be done with it?) If the NFL could find a way to make people care about this exhibition, then it too could be a huge money-maker. Here are some ideas for a way to make this game some fun:

1. Stop letting the conference runners up coach the Pro-Bowl. “Congratulations for being the third and fourth best teams in the NFL.” That doesn’t even make sense. Let’s do this. NFL coaching or playing legends coach the game. These guys are allowed to do Dancing With The Stars, but are not allowed to be affiliated with the Pro Bowl? Really? Tell me you wouldn’t love to see Don Shula vs. Jimmy Johnson. You can’t. Tell me you don’t want to see Deion Sanders vs. Shannon Sharpe. Can you imagine the post-game interviews? You know how when Tyson fought nobodies after he fell apart? Remember how half the reason you got the Pay-Per-View was to listen to Mike try to talk? This is the same thing. Scenario:

Shannon: “WETRIEDTORUNTHEBALLBUTCOULDNTGETITSTARTEDONTHEGROUNDSOWETOOKTOTHEAIR” (this is not a grammatical error)

Deion: “You know how it is, baby! Things do what things do and we didn’t do some things that they did! Its…just…football…baby!”

2. Speaking of money, what makes it? Fans. So let’s do this: Instead of punishing fans in the NFL cities, do like the NBA. Rotate the game (sorry Honolulu). And to heck with warm weather cities only. This is football, throw on your spandex and get out there. In the NBA, season ticket holders get first dibs on a package for the weekend. For instance, in 1997 when the game was in Cleveland, I had season tickets. I chose to go to the Saturday night stuff as opposed to the game.  I could have had both though. Who benefits from having the game in Hawaii? Nobody except the players who, at last check, were making enough money to fly themselves there any time between February and mid May and wealthy tourists and honeymooners.

3. No punting, no field goals except the final two minutes of each quarter. This is the Pro Bowl. Nobody wants to watch guys kick. We want points. The game already doesn’t mean anything, so why does it matter if someone has to go for it on fourth and nine from their own five?

The NFL is the most well run, closely followed, and possibly most popular sport we have. It is clearly time that its All-Star even reflects that. Enough alienating fans, players bowing out, and people forgetting that the game is on. You know that a game is pointless when all the talk on the ESPN is about how much nobody wants to talk about it.