Time for Steve McNair to Retire
By Phillip Backert
11/14/07

It has become more apparent over the last few weeks as I have watched the Baltimore Ravens suffer week in and week out to score touchdowns that the career of a great quarterback is coming to an end.  Steve McNair has aged overnight and his final play may have come at the end of last Sunday’s game against the Cincinnati Bengals when his last play of that game was him losing the grip of the football as he went back to pass.  

McNair came to Baltimore before the start of the 2006 season and he was looked as the last missing piece to an already impressive team ready to make a run at the Super Bowl.  In his first year, McNair led the Ravens to a 13-3 record, division crown in the AFC North and a first round bye in the playoffs.  He threw for 16 touchdowns, and exemplified the reputation of being a clutch player and a team leader.  However, the last two games of the season including the playoff loss against the Indianapolis Colts, McNair threw 3 interceptions and no touchdowns.  

This year the struggles for the Ravens offense started almost immediately.  In Week 1, McNair was responsible for 4 turnovers as he lost three fumbles and threw one interception.  McNair also injured his groin in the game and according to coaches the injury affected his play for some time after.  However, he sat out the last two weeks before the Ravens Week 8 bye, and when he returned in Week 9, he proclaimed himself completely healthy.  With the injury excuse gone, McNair’s play did not improve.  He threw for an embarrassing 63 yards against the Pittsburgh Steelers on Monday Night Football and turned the ball over twice.  This past week against the Bengals, McNair showed that age may have finally caught up with him.  McNair lost 2 fumbles, one while running for a first down and having a defensive lineman catch up to him and the strip the ball.  The other, when he was attempting to throw the ball.  McNair also threw an interception in the game without throwing a touchdown.  This season in six starts, McNair has 2 touchdown passes, but none since September 30th.   He has also committed 11 turnovers (4 interceptions, 7 fumbles).    

The one-time MVP winner has appeared to lose confidence.  After Sunday’s loss to the Bengals, McNair said he would agree if the Ravens decided to start Boller ahead of him. Coach Brian Billick who is on the hot seat himself because of the underachieving Ravens has that hard choice to make.  Bench a borderline Hall of Famer for an underachieving former first round pick in Kyle Boller, or hope that the 34 year old quarterback could break out of the season long slump that he has been in.  Luckily for Billick, McNair complained of left shoulder soreness this week and he is now out for the next 2-3 weeks.  Boller will take over the reigns of the struggling offense in one last dash of hope that he could become the quarterback the Ravens envisioned when they drafted him in 2003.

McNair has been a class act throughout his entire career, but he has proved over the course of this season that his skills have diminished.  One of the hardest decisions an athlete can make is when to retire.  It has become painful to watch McNair play this season, but I want my memory of Steve McNair to be the one that led the Ravens to a 13-3 record, not one that shows him having a hard time throwing the ball longer than 10 yards.