Touchdown Celebrations.  What's so Wrong?

by Eric Rose
NFL Analyst
1/8/08


Celebrations have always been a part of sport; from hugs, to dancing, to falling to one knee to praise god. Many athletes are now being punished for celebrating when it’s not harming anyone. Athletes with enthusiasm and passion are what fans come to see. What’s better than watching Brett Favre give a high five to a referee when he scores a touchdown? Should Favre be punished for being so proud of the fact that his team scored to take the lead? No. There’s no reason athletes today shouldn’t be allowed to set an example of having fun. From the minute we begin playing sports, coaches and parents have told us to “have fun.” So aren’t these players getting punished for the same thing we are teaching our little leaguers?

Just the other day, while playing Kentucky in the Music City Bowl, Florida State corner Tony Carter intercepted a pass and ran it in for a touchdown. Upon crossing the goal line, Carter leaped into the air and did a full front flip, landing on his feet. Carter was flagged for the flip and his team was also flagged for excessive celebration; so they ended up kicking from their own 7 yard line! It’s almost like the referees thought the Seminoles needed an obstacle bigger than losing 36 of their players. Although it could have gotten Tony Carter hurt, it was his choice to do it and he deserved to celebrate. Some people may argue that he should “act like he’s scored before” but I don’t find that relevant. He’s a defensive player who only touches the ball when he makes a spectacular play that deserves being celebrated. 

When Indiana Hoosier, James Hardy caught a touchdown pass in the first game of the season this year, he knelt down and point up to the sky in remembrance of his former coach, Terry Hoeppner who died this past June of complications of a brain tumor. When I saw Hardy take a knee and show respect for his coach by point at him it reminded me that many athletes still have passion and love for their sport. This would have been one of the best stories of the year had the referee not shown up to the game that day. Hardy was panelized 15 yards for “excessive celebration”. Of course the Indiana fans, players and coaches didn’t care because they knew Hardy was just showing respect for his former coach.

Too many athletes are being scrutinized because of their love and passion for the game. Is it really necessary to have a penalty for jumping up in the air after making a good play? At least that’s something that today’s youth can look at because it shows the love and passion, and most importantly the fun these players put in the game.  Because in reality its all about having a little fun. I believe strongly that if it is not offensive, harmful or a negative influence than it shouldn’t be considered a penalty.